There’s seriously no downside for Blackrock and Vanguard to push this shit. #1–they don’t actually own the shares. They make money off the fees of the index fund that they manage, and those fees are higher if the fund is green-washed
#2–that index fund also controls all the other companies in the S&P500. So, when one business does something dumb, their market share is taken up by another company also controlled by Blackrock/Vanguard.
They’ve effectively cornered the entire market without putting up their own capital. They did it by having the lowest fees of all the other index funds, so everyone that has a 401k puts all their capital with these investment firms. The firms take all the voting rights, charge a small management fee, and control the world. They get to charge a higher management fee for social issue index funds. So they just make every S&P500 company follow those guidelines out of their own convenience.
#2–that index fund also controls all the other companies in the S&P500. So, when one business does something dumb, their market share is taken up by another company also controlled by Blackrock/Vanguard.
They’ve effectively cornered the entire market without putting up their own capital. They did it by having the lowest fees of all the other index funds, so everyone that has a 401k puts all their capital with these investment firms. The firms take all the voting rights, charge a small management fee, and control the world. They get to charge a higher management fee for social issue index funds. So they just make every S&P500 company follow those guidelines out of their own convenience.