YotaAtieToo
Thick skull
Those other tires you listed look great.
I wouldn’t run that old ITP, personally.
My next set of tires for the Geo will just be General ATx in 265/70R15. I think it’s like 29.5” but a legal street tire.
Lame, you'll hate them offroad. No way you drive it enough to need an at.
The Pagonia SXT you like?
I have no interest in running LT tires on a geo anymore. I’m a huge fan of the lighter SXS tires and their kick ass tread compound.
If you don't want to try a new tire, I'd buy the 3 and give it a shot. You'll know quick if that old tire is junk and worst case you have to buy a 4th?