Probably one of the (if now the) most personal preferences to have on a bike.
I tried so many over the years....many that you mentioned. But settled on these as my every bike, every time, can-ride-it-all-day saddle: The Specialized Power Mirror with ***anium rails in a 155 width.
EDIT: This was discovered purely by accident. Was riding my usual ERGON and the carbon rail broke, so went to a shop to get a saddle to make it through the rest of the trip. Got a Specialized Power one to use. It was a "Wait.....this feels awesome!" replacement. Came home....went to my usual shop to get a Power for my Enduro bike and they said try it with the Mirror addition. I never looked back.