So same as the $2,000 RDT pump? Even with the losses, seems like for $700, it could be a good fit for a crawler application that needs maximum speed near idle and rarely hits 6,000 RPM. I want to say I've seen Eric post that the RDT is good for 8,000-9,000 RPM though? I am sure the RDT is a superior product, but for $700 vs. $2,000, is it really worth it for a recreational application? I was doing some math the other day, and it takes a shit ton of volume to have reasonably fast steering with a 3" ram.
The Scott's pump is a Dynamic brand gear pump paired with his own bearing block and the pump itself is .85 c.i./rev or 13cc displacement so it's not much larger than our Pro Series TC which is 11cc. Our RDT is 20cc by comparison.
Volumetric efficiency is the big difference where gear pumps suffer, especially at low rpm. Because they work by trapping oil in between the teeth of a gear and the wall of the pump housing, there is always a clearance gap resulting in internal leakage from cavity to cavity. At low rpm and high pressure, the efficiency of these pumps (actual flow rate versus theoretical flow rate) can drop as low as 70%. With a sliding vane type pump like the TC and RDT, volumetric efficiency will be closer to 90-95% at the same conditions so despite having slightly smaller displacement, customers that have swapped over to our Pro Series TC have consistently reported better steering feel at low rpm and across the board.
The numbers that commonly circulate for the Scotts pump of 20 GPM are the theoretical flow for a 13cc displacement pump at 5500 RPM although in reality, with any non-flow controlled pump including vane pumps (i.e. billet TT pumps and PSC "race" CBR pumps), you will reach a max flow rate where the pump just can't pull any more fluid in from the reservoir and begins to cavitate. This is entirely dependent on the size of the feed hose, reservoir design, and tank pressure but with a -12 feed, I can tell you a Scotts pump won't put out more than 12 GPM and with a -16 feed hose will be around 15 GPM max.
Once you reach around 6 GPM (our standard Pro TC), you are able to keep up with most any orbital used for crawling and with rear steer, you aren't exactly able to utilize double the flow so pushing more through the system provides no real extra benefit other than rear steer quickness. For people that need a little extra, we don't advertise it but we do make our TC pumps up to an 8 GPM output limit. I just like to go through the complete system with people before offering it because the rest of the system becomes that much more critical at the higher rate.
As for RPM, I have no problems sending our Pro Series TC up to 8K RPM or even a little higher for short durations. I try to keep the RDT limited to 7500 and have several trophy trucks running up in the 6-7K rpm range for extended periods with no concerning wear. Other pumps like our Trail Series TC or a gear pump, I would try to keep down around 6000 to 6500 max if possible.
Over the past two years since launching the Pro Series TC, we have built and sold hundreds of them, many for single pump front and rear steer buggies and there have been very few drivers that felt like they needed any more power than this pump could provide.