Thought I'd bump this with some anecdotal experience.
21 6.7 f350 Tremor 3.55 Platinum vs. 22 7.3 F250 Tremor 4.30 Lariat. Gas has Pedal Monster and an exhaust (bought it used...)
just got back from 2000 miles towing. 1/2 with empty car trailer (~2500 lbs), 1/2 loaded (~7000-7500... about 500# in the truck). Same route that I last towed with the 6.7. Only difference is which leg the car trailer was loaded.
Mileage... 6.7 got about 15 w/ empty trailer, 13-13.5 loaded. 7.3 got about 11.5 empty trailer and 9-10 loaded. All at ~75mph.
Power... 7.3 is just fine... but the 6.7 spoiled me. Much more relaxing to tow in the 6.7.
Acceleration... 6.7 - no contest. Much better experience in the diesel.
Braking... 6.7's exhaust brake was a spoiler. I HATE the compression braking program in the 7.3 tow/haul mode. I don't need the trans shifting to 3rd and pegging the limiter... let me use the brakes. Additionally, the trans does NOT like to upshift after it's chosen to down shift... it'll stay in whatever gear it's downshifted two until it damned well decides it's ready to upshift... That's annoying AF to me.
Daily driving... 7.3 all day. It "feels" smaller and lighter... losing that extra ~800 lbs on the front is very noticeable. I did miss it a bit while towing.
Overall... If it wasn't for the CP4, I'd have kept the Diesel. The 7.3 is a great engine... and I'd say is much more comparable in experience to my 2016 6.7 than to the 21.
If I was buying again... I'd probably go gas... But if I was regularly towing over 7500, I'd buy a 6.7 and invest in a CP3 conversion and call it done.